What can a landlord deduct from a tenancy deposit, and how are disputes resolved?
What landlords can and can't deduct from a deposit, who has to prove it, and how free ADR with DPS, mydeposits or TDS resolves disagreements.

A landlord can only deduct from a tenancy deposit to cover genuine financial loss caused by the tenant — rent arrears, damage beyond normal use, missing items, or unpaid bills the tenancy agreement made the tenant's responsibility. A landlord cannot deduct for ordinary deterioration that happens simply because someone lived in the property, known as fair wear and tear. If landlord and tenant cannot agree on what's fair, either side can take the disagreement to free, independent dispute resolution run by the tenancy deposit scheme holding the deposit, rather than going straight to court.
The legal starting point
Deposits taken for tenancies in England have to be protected in one of three government-authorised schemes — the Deposit Protection Service (DPS), mydeposits, or the Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS) — within 30 days, and the tenant must be given prescribed information about where it's held. That duty, and what happens if a landlord gets it wrong, comes from the Housing Act 2004 and is covered in full in our guide to tenancy deposit protection in England. This article picks up from the end of the tenancy: once a tenant moves out, what can actually be taken out of the deposit, and what happens when the two sides disagree.

Fair wear and tear versus damage
There is no statutory definition of "fair wear and tear" in UK law. It's a concept the courts and the deposit schemes have built up from the ordinary meaning of the words and from the way deposit disputes get decided in practice, not from a line in an Act of Parliament. In broad terms, it describes the gradual deterioration that happens to carpets, paintwork, fixtures and furnishings simply through normal daily use over the length of the tenancy, by tenants behaving reasonably. A patch of worn carpet in a hallway after a three-year tenancy, faded curtains, or small scuff marks on a wall are typically treated as fair wear and tear — the landlord bears that cost, because it would have happened to some degree regardless of who was living there.
Damage is different: it's deterioration caused by accident, neglect, misuse, or something going beyond ordinary living — a cigarette burn in a carpet, a hole punched in a door, stains from not cleaning up a spill, or a broken window. Those costs can reasonably be deducted from the deposit, provided the landlord can show the tenant caused them and that the amount claimed reflects the actual cost of putting things right (and, in most cases, an allowance for the fact the item wasn't brand new).
Length of tenancy, the age and quality of the item in question, and how many occupants there were all affect where the line sits. A six-month tenancy and a six-year tenancy don't produce the same amount of fair wear, and a landlord can't charge for full replacement of an item that was already worn out before the tenant moved in. Where the answer genuinely isn't clear-cut, that's exactly the kind of judgement call a scheme's dispute resolution service — or independent legal advice — exists to settle; it's not something either side should assume they're automatically right about.
Who has to prove what
The deposit belongs to the tenant until the landlord can show a valid reason to keep some of it back. That means the burden of proof sits with the landlord, not the tenant. A tenant does not have to prove the property was left in good condition — a landlord (or agent) proposing a deduction has to produce evidence that justifies it: what the damage or missing item was, what it's costing to fix or replace, and that the tenant was responsible for it rather than normal use or pre-existing condition. A bare assertion that "the carpet needs replacing" isn't enough on its own.

Why the inventory matters here
This is where the check-in and check-out inventory becomes central. Without a signed, dated inventory describing the property's condition at the start of the tenancy — ideally with photos or video — a landlord has no baseline to compare the end-of-tenancy condition against, and a deduction claim becomes very hard to support with evidence. We've covered how to put one together properly in our guide to the check-in and check-out inventory. If a dispute does end up in front of an adjudicator, the inventory — plus check-out report, photos, receipts and correspondence — is usually the single most important piece of evidence either side can submit.
How the dispute resolution service works
When landlord and tenant can't agree on deductions, each of the three schemes runs its own Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) service rather than requiring either side to go to court. The core shape of the process is the same across DPS, mydeposits and TDS:
- It's free to use for both landlord and tenant.
- Each side submits written evidence — the inventory, check-out report, photos, invoices, messages — rather than attending a hearing. There's no in-person meeting, and the adjudicator doesn't visit the property.
- An independent adjudicator employed by the scheme reviews everything submitted and decides the case on the balance of probabilities — essentially, which version of events the evidence makes more likely.
- Because the burden of proof sits with the landlord, if the evidence doesn't clearly justify a deduction, the adjudicator will typically return that portion of the deposit to the tenant.
- The decision is final and binding on both parties within the scheme's process — neither side can appeal it through the scheme itself, though going to court over a point of law generally remains an option afterwards, and either party can choose court instead of ADR from the outset.
Using the scheme's dispute service isn't compulsory, but because it's free and evidence-based, it's usually a faster and cheaper route than litigation for a disagreement over a few hundred pounds of deductions. Which scheme runs the process depends on which one is protecting that particular deposit — the information given to the tenant at the start of the tenancy should say which.
Where this is genuinely open to interpretation
Whether a specific mark, smell, or item of wear counts as "fair" is often a judgement call rather than a fixed rule, and reasonable people — including adjudicators — can land on different conclusions on similar-looking facts. If a deduction is contested and the amount at stake matters to you, get independent legal advice or use the scheme's dispute resolution service rather than relying on a confident-sounding rule of thumb from either side.
This article is general information, not legal advice, and reflects our understanding of the position as of October 2026. Deposit disputes turn on the specific facts and evidence in each case, so confirm your position with a solicitor or your deposit scheme's own guidance before relying on it.
If you're a landlord dealing with an end-of-tenancy deduction, or a tenant unsure what you can challenge, Atlas Estates can help with the practical side of managing the process — inventories, check-outs and liaising with the scheme — though we can't give legal advice. For what we charge to manage a let, see our fees. Call us on 0161 710 4510 or visit us at 12–14 Midland Street, Manchester M12 6LB.