Landlord guide

Can a tenant withhold rent because of disrepair?

Why there is no general right to stop paying rent over disrepair, the narrow set-off exception, and what tenants should do instead.

Atlas Estates · 12 November 2026 ·6 min read
Can a tenant withhold rent because of disrepair?

There is no general right in English law for a tenant to simply stop paying rent because a landlord has not carried out repairs. Rent and repairs are normally treated as separate, independent obligations under a tenancy agreement, not as conditions on each other — so a repair problem, however genuine, does not by itself excuse non-payment of rent, unless the tenancy agreement itself says otherwise.

Why rent and repairs are usually treated separately

Under an ordinary residential tenancy, the tenant's duty to pay rent and the landlord's duty to repair are generally independent covenants. This is the standard common-law and contract-law position, not a rule found in one specific statutory provision. We checked the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 and the Housing Act 1988 directly for a section stating that rent and repairs are independent, or that sets out a right to withhold rent for disrepair, and found no such provision in either Act. The closest relevant statutory material is the landlord's repairing covenant at section 11 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, which sets out what the landlord must keep in repair — but it says nothing about the tenant's rent obligation being conditional on that duty being met. So "rent and repairs are independent" should be understood as the general legal position, not a named section.

A tenancy agreement can, in principle, be drafted differently — for example by expressly linking rent to specific repair failures — but that is unusual in standard residential tenancies, and most tenants will be on terms where the general independence rule applies.

A dripping tap over a plain sink
A dripping tap over a plain sink

The narrow exception: set-off for repairs the tenant pays for themselves

There is one recognised, but narrow, exception that is often confused with "withholding rent" generally. Where a landlord is under a repairing obligation, has been given reasonable notice of the disrepair and a reasonable opportunity to carry out the repair, and still fails to act, a tenant who then pays for that repair out of their own pocket may in some circumstances be able to deduct the reasonable cost from future rent. This is usually described as a form of set-off or equitable deduction, rather than a right to withhold rent outright.

This principle appears to be a creature of general case law rather than a specific statutory right. We have not independently verified a specific case establishing it, so we are not naming one here — only describing the general shape of the doctrine.

In practice this route is narrow and risky:

  • The tenant must normally have given the landlord proper written notice and a genuine, reasonable opportunity to fix the problem before paying for the work themselves.
  • The cost deducted has to be reasonable and reasonably evidenced — an inflated, unnecessary, or unrelated repair cost is unlikely to be protected.
  • The landlord can simply dispute that the conditions were met, dispute the amount, or dispute that the repair was even their responsibility, and pursue the tenant for the "missing" rent regardless.
  • Timing, evidence, and reasonableness all matter, and getting any of them wrong leaves the tenant simply short on rent with no valid defence.

This is a long way from a tenant deciding, on their own initiative, to stop paying rent generally because a landlord has not responded to a repair request. That broader kind of withholding is not protected by this exception.

What withholding rent without that justification actually risks

If a tenant stops paying rent in general response to disrepair, without the narrow set-off conditions being met, the practical and legal risks are real:

  • Rent arrears accrue regardless of whether the landlord is in the wrong on the repair issue. A repair breach and a rent arrears position are legally distinct problems.
  • The landlord can pursue a possession claim on rent-arrears grounds. Our guide on what happens when a tenant stops paying rent sets out that process in more detail.
  • A court dealing with an arrears or possession claim can still find the tenant liable for the arrears even where the landlord was genuinely in breach of their repairing obligations. The disrepair and the arrears are often dealt with as separate claims or counterclaims, rather than the disrepair automatically operating as a defence.
  • A tenant who builds up significant arrears while disputing a repair issue can end up worse off than if they had kept paying rent and pursued the disrepair separately — arrears can affect references, deposit claims, and standing in any court proceedings.

None of this means a genuine repair obligation can be ignored by a landlord just because the tenant has no right to simply withhold rent. A landlord who lets a repair obligation under section 11 go unaddressed is still exposed to the tenant's own claim for disrepair, and potentially to formal intervention, regardless of whether the tenant is up to date with rent.

An envelope and pen resting beside a closed folder
An envelope and pen resting beside a closed folder

What a tenant should do instead

Rather than stopping payment and hoping that forces the landlord's hand, the more effective and lower-risk approach is usually to:

  • Report the disrepair to the landlord or agent in writing, and keep a clear record of every report, response (or lack of one), and date.
  • Where the disrepair is serious — a significant hazard rather than a minor snag — consider reporting it to the local authority's environmental health team, who can assess it under the Housing Act 2004 Housing Health and Safety Rating System (HHSRS). Our guide on damp and mould duties for landlords covers how that process works for one common type of hazard.
  • Keep paying rent as normal while pursuing the repair issue through these routes, or through a formal claim or counterclaim for disrepair, rather than through unilateral non-payment.
  • Take independent advice before relying on the set-off exception specifically, given how easy it is to get the notice, reasonableness, and evidence requirements wrong.

For landlords, the lesson is the mirror image: a slow or absent response to a legitimate repair request does not just risk a tenant trying (wrongly) to withhold rent — it risks the landlord's own exposure under section 11 and, where relevant, HHSRS, regardless of the rent position. Our fee structure is set out on our fees page, and keeping repairs on top of things is generally the more effective way to avoid both problems arising together.

This article is general information, not legal advice, and reflects the position as we understand it in November 2026. Tenants and landlords should take independent legal advice, including from a solicitor, before withholding rent, relying on a set-off deduction, or pursuing a disrepair claim.

If you are a tenant or landlord dealing with a disrepair dispute in Manchester, Atlas Estates can be contacted on 0161 710 4510 or at 12–14 Midland Street, Manchester M12 6LB.

← All articles